Buying a used car can be one of the smartest financial moves you make — if you know what to look for. With the right checklist and a little extra diligence, you can avoid the common traps, overpaying, or worse — ending up with a vehicle that costs you thousands in repairs.
In this guide, I’ll walk you through a pro-level used car checklist so you can shop with confidence.
Before you even browse listings, take a few minutes to ask yourself:
How many people will you regularly transport?
What is the vehicle’s primary purpose?
What kind of fuel economy do you need?
It’s important to match your lifestyle with your purchase. For example, if you're looking at third-row SUVs and towing a camper, you're not likely to get stellar gas mileage. Make a list of non-negotiables and nice-to-haves — this will help narrow your search.
Start with trusted platforms like CarGurus, AutoTrader, or even Facebook Marketplace. Look at:
Price vs. mileage
Trim packages and features
Market comparisons
Be aware that two cars may look identical but be priced very differently depending on features like heated seats, navigation, or all-wheel drive. Not every vehicle will be equipped the same — even within the same model.
A clean Carfax or AutoCheck is not a green light — but a bad one is definitely a red flag. Use these reports to:
Eliminate vehicles with reported accidents or title issues
Check for ownership history (multiple owners in a short time can be suspicious)
Watch for branded titles like salvage, flood, or rebuilt
Remember: "Trust but verify." Always follow up with a licensed mechanic, even if the history report looks good.
Before the test drive:
Examine panel gaps (uneven spacing can signal previous bodywork)
Check for paint mismatches
Look under the hood for fluid levels and leaks
Use your nose — burnt smells could mean oil leaks or other issues
During the test drive:
Roll the windows up, turn the radio off, and listen to the engine
Get the RPMs over 2500 and feel how the car drives
Check every button, power seat, and window
Avoid:
“As-is” sales without verified title history
Salvaged or rebuilt titles
Vehicles with unrealistically low prices
Pressure to buy immediately
If it feels too good to be true — it probably is. Use a bank or trusted third party to verify title documents and hold funds in escrow if needed.
Buying a used car can absolutely save you thousands of dollars — but only if you slow down and do it right. From identifying your needs, verifying vehicle condition, and inspecting paperwork, a little caution goes a long way.
If you need help with a used car purchase or want a second opinion, I’m here for you. Let’s make sure your next car is a smart one.
– Ronnie Haskins